Essential Roof Underlayment Types for Portland, Oregon Homes

When considering the structure and protection of your home in Portland, Oregon, the roof is undoubtedly one of the most critical components. While shingles or tiles are the visible line of defense against the elements, there’s a vital, often unseen layer beneath them that plays a crucial role in preventing water damage and extending the life of your roof: the roof underlayment. Underlayment acts as a secondary barrier, providing added protection to the roof deck below, especially in areas prone to heavy rain and moisture, like the Pacific Northwest. Understanding the different types of underlayment available is key to ensuring your roofing system offers maximum durability and protection.

What is Roof Underlayment and Why is it Important?

Roof underlayment is a layer of protective material installed directly on top of the roof deck (typically plywood or OSB sheathing) before the final roofing material, such as shingles, tiles, or metal panels, is applied. It serves several essential functions:

1. Secondary Water Barrier: The primary purpose of underlayment is to provide a backup layer of protection in case water penetrates the primary roofing material (e.g., through damaged or missing shingles, wind-driven rain, or ice dams). It helps channel water away from the roof deck and into the gutters, preventing leaks that could damage the structure of your home, insulation, and interior finishes.
2. Protection During Installation: Underlayment shields the roof deck from rain and moisture during the roofing process itself, before the final weatherproofing layer is installed. This is particularly important during multi-day installations.
3. Smooth Surface: It creates a smooth, even surface for the roofing material to lie on, which can improve the aesthetic appearance and performance of the finished roof.
4. Deck Protection: It helps protect the roof deck from moisture, preventing rot, mold, and mildew growth, which can compromise the structural integrity of the deck.
5. Code Compliance: Building codes often require the installation of specific types or amounts of underlayment, particularly in certain climate zones or on roofs with a low slope.

Ignoring the importance of underlayment or choosing an inappropriate type can lead to premature roof failure, costly leaks, and structural damage down the line. It's a relatively small investment compared to the total cost of a roof replacement but provides significant long-term benefits.

Types of Roof Underlayment

There are three primary types of roof underlayment commonly used today: asphalt-saturated felt, synthetic underlayment, and rubberized asphalt (often referred to as ice and water shield). Each has distinct characteristics, advantages, and disadvantages.

Asphalt-Saturated Felt Underlayment

Traditionally, asphalt-saturated felt, often called "felt paper" or "tar paper," was the standard underlayment used in residential roofing. It is made from a base mat of organic felt or fiberglass, which is then saturated with asphalt to make it water-resistant.

Composition and Characteristics

Felt underlayment comes in different weights, most commonly 15-pound (#15 felt) and 30-pound (#30 felt). The number refers to the weight per 100 square feet.

• #15 Felt: This is the lighter option, typically around 0.020 to 0.025 inches thick. It's less expensive but also less durable and tear-resistant than #30 felt. It provides a basic level of protection.
• #30 Felt: This is a heavier, thicker version (around 0.030 to 0.035 inches thick) offering better tear resistance and a longer lifespan than #15 felt. It provides a more robust secondary barrier.

Both types are installed by rolling them out horizontally across the roof deck, starting from the eaves, and overlapping the edges. They are typically fastened using staples or roofing nails.

Pros of Asphalt-Saturated Felt

• Cost-Effective: Felt underlayment is generally the least expensive option available, making it an attractive choice for budget-conscious projects.
• Proven Track Record: It has been used for decades and its performance characteristics are well-understood.
• Permeability: Standard felt is considered 'permeable' or 'breathable', meaning it allows some moisture vapor from inside the attic to escape through the roof system. This can be an advantage in preventing moisture buildup within the roof structure, provided the attic ventilation is also adequate.

Cons of Asphalt-Saturated Felt

• Durability: Felt is susceptible to tearing during installation, especially #15 felt. It can also become brittle in cold weather and soft in hot weather, making it challenging to work with in extreme temperatures.
• Water Resistance: While asphalt-saturated, felt is not completely waterproof. Prolonged exposure to water can cause it to absorb moisture, wrinkle, and potentially degrade, reducing its effectiveness as a barrier over time.
• Weight: #30 felt is quite heavy, which can make installation more physically demanding.
• Limited Lifespan: Its lifespan is generally shorter than synthetic or rubberized asphalt underlayments.

When planning a roofing project, especially a full replacement, understanding the costs associated with different underlayment options is crucial for budgeting.
Get your free instant roof estimate

Synthetic Underlayment

Synthetic underlayment is a newer technology that has gained significant popularity over the past couple of decades. It is manufactured from polymers, such as polypropylene or polyethylene, often reinforced with fiberglass.

Composition and Characteristics

Synthetic underlayment is significantly lighter and much stronger than asphalt felt. It typically comes in rolls that are larger than felt rolls, covering more area per roll. It is also installed by rolling it out horizontally and overlapping edges, but specific installation instructions regarding overlap and fastening methods vary by manufacturer. Many synthetic underlayments feature a textured or coated surface for better traction during installation.

Pros of Synthetic Underlayment

• Superior Durability and Tear Resistance: Synthetic underlayment is highly resistant to tearing, making it much easier and safer to install without damaging the barrier. It can withstand foot traffic and exposure to the elements for longer periods during construction.
• Excellent Water Resistance: Most synthetic underlayments are highly water-resistant, effectively shedding water and preventing leaks even under challenging conditions. Some are even waterproof.
• Lightweight: Despite their strength, synthetic underlayments are much lighter than felt, making them easier to carry and install, especially on steep roofs.
• Dimensional Stability: Unlike felt, synthetic underlayment does not absorb moisture and is not prone to wrinkling or becoming brittle/soft with temperature changes. It lies flat and remains stable.
• Mold and Mildew Resistance: Being inorganic, synthetic underlayment is not a food source for mold or mildew.
• Longer Exposure Time: Many synthetic underlayments are designed to be exposed to UV rays and weather for extended periods (weeks or even months) during construction without degrading, providing more flexibility in project scheduling.

Cons of Synthetic Underlayment

• Cost: Synthetic underlayment is more expensive than asphalt-saturated felt, though the cost difference may be offset by faster installation and greater durability.
• Less Breathable: Some synthetic underlayments have lower vapor permeability than felt, which could potentially trap moisture vapor if attic ventilation is inadequate. However, many modern synthetics are engineered to be 'vapor permeable' or 'breathable' while remaining water-resistant.

A worker installs synthetic or felt underlayment on a roof deck before the final roofing material is applied.

Rubberized Asphalt Underlayment (Ice and Water Shield)

Rubberized asphalt underlayment, commonly known as ice and water shield or peel-and-stick underlayment, is a premium type of underlayment designed for maximum protection against water intrusion. It is composed of a mixture of asphalt and rubber polymers, which gives it elastic, self-sealing properties.

Composition and Characteristics

This underlayment is typically applied with an adhesive backing that sticks directly to the roof deck. It is available in various thicknesses, but its key feature is its ability to create a watertight seal around fasteners (like nails or staples) driven through it. When a fastener penetrates the material, the rubberized asphalt seals tightly around the shank, preventing water from entering.

Ice and water shield is not typically used across the entire roof deck. Instead, building codes often mandate its installation in specific vulnerable areas, including:

• Eaves: Along the lower edge of the roof, where ice dams can form in colder climates or where water might back up due to clogged gutters.
• Valleys: The areas where two roof sections meet, which channel significant amounts of water.
• Around Penetrations: Skylights, chimneys, vents, and pipes, where the roof surface is interrupted and flashing is used. Ice and water shield provides an extra layer of protection beneath the flashing.
• Along Rakes: Sometimes required along gable ends in areas with high winds or specific code requirements.

Pros of Rubberized Asphalt Underlayment

• Exceptional Water Protection: It provides the highest level of water resistance, creating a virtually waterproof barrier.
• Self-Sealing: The self-sealing property around fasteners is a critical advantage, preventing leaks that can occur around nail holes in felt or standard synthetic underlayment.
• Adhesive Backing: The adhesive creates a strong bond with the roof deck, preventing wind uplift and providing a continuous seal.
• Ideal for Vulnerable Areas: It is specifically designed and highly effective for use in areas most susceptible to leaks, such as eaves prone to ice dams or busy roof valleys.

Cons of Rubberized Asphalt Underlayment

• Cost: This is the most expensive type of underlayment.
• Installation Difficulty: The peel-and-stick nature requires careful installation to avoid wrinkles and ensure proper adhesion. Once it sticks, it's difficult to reposition. It also requires specific temperature conditions for optimal adhesion.
• Vapor Permeability: Most rubberized asphalt underlayments are vapor impermeable, meaning they do not allow moisture vapor to pass through. This reinforces the need for proper attic ventilation to manage internal moisture.
• Heat Sensitivity: Some types can be sensitive to high temperatures during installation.

Rubberized asphalt underlayment, also known as ice and water shield, is applied to vulnerable areas like eaves and valleys for maximum water protection.

Choosing the Right Underlayment for Your Home

Selecting the appropriate underlayment involves considering several factors specific to your home and location.

1. Climate: This is perhaps the most significant factor. In a rainy climate like Portland, Oregon, robust water resistance is paramount. While standard felt provides basic protection, synthetic underlayment offers superior resistance to wind-driven rain. In areas where freezing temperatures and snow are common, rubberized asphalt (ice and water shield) is essential along eaves to prevent leaks caused by ice dams. Even without significant snow, Portland can experience freezing events where ice dams are a risk, especially on roofs with inadequate insulation or ventilation.
2. Roof Slope: Low-slope roofs (pitches below 4:12) are more susceptible to water backup than steeper roofs. Building codes often require enhanced underlayment protection, such as multiple layers of felt or specific waterproof membranes, on low-slope sections.
3. Budget: Asphalt felt is the most budget-friendly option, while synthetic and rubberized asphalt are more expensive. However, the added cost of a higher-quality underlayment is often a small percentage of the total roof replacement cost and provides significant long-term value in terms of protection and longevity.
4. Type of Roofing Material: While underlayment is compatible with most common roofing materials (asphalt shingles, metal, tile, etc.), some manufacturers recommend specific underlayments to work best with their products or to meet warranty requirements. For example, some metal roofs benefit from a breathable synthetic underlayment to prevent condensation issues.
5. Building Codes: Always ensure the chosen underlayment meets or exceeds local building code requirements in your area. Codes specify minimum standards for underlayment type and placement, particularly for ice and water shield at eaves and valleys based on climate zones.

Considering different roofing options and materials, including underlayment types, can feel complex. For budgeting and comparing costs based on material choices, an instant estimate can be very helpful.
Get a quick roof estimate online

The Roof Deck: The Foundation Beneath

Understanding underlayment also requires acknowledging the layer beneath it: the roof deck. The deck, typically made of plywood or OSB (Oriented Strand Board), is the structural surface of the roof. It provides the base for fastening the underlayment and the roofing material.

Importance of a Sound Deck

A healthy roof deck is crucial for the performance of the entire roofing system.

• Structural Support: It must be strong enough to support the weight of the roofing materials, snow loads, and wind uplift forces.
• Fastening Base: It provides a solid substrate for nails or staples used to secure the underlayment and shingles. A weak or deteriorated deck will not hold fasteners securely.
• Smooth Surface: A properly installed deck provides a flat, even surface for the underlayment and subsequent layers.

Deck Issues Affecting Underlayment

Moisture damage is the primary enemy of roof decks. Leaks from a failing roof or inadequate ventilation can cause the wood to rot, warp, or become soft. Installing new underlayment and roofing over a damaged deck is a critical mistake. The new fasteners won't hold, and the underlayment won't lie flat or provide a proper seal.

During a roof replacement, the contractor will inspect the existing deck and replace any damaged sections. This is an essential step to ensure the new underlayment and roofing material perform as intended and last for their expected lifespan.

A roofer installs plywood sheathing, which forms the roof deck – the structural layer beneath the underlayment.

Installation Process and Best Practices

Proper installation is just as important as choosing the right type of underlayment. Even the highest quality material will fail if installed incorrectly. While specific steps vary slightly depending on the underlayment type and manufacturer, the general process follows key principles.

1. Deck Preparation: The roof deck must be clean, dry, and free of debris. Any damaged sections of the deck should be repaired or replaced. Existing fasteners (like staples from old felt) should be removed or hammered flat.
2. Starting Point: Installation typically begins at the lowest point of the roof – the eaves.
3. Horizontal Application: Underlayment is rolled out horizontally across the roof deck, parallel to the eaves.
4. Overlaps: Subsequent courses (rows) of underlayment must overlap the lower courses to ensure water flows over the seams, not into them. Manufacturer specifications dictate the required overlap, which is often 2 to 4 inches for felt and synthetic, and can be 6 inches or more for ice and water shield seams. Vertical laps (where two rolls meet end-to-end) also require specific overlap amounts.
5. Fastening: Felt and synthetic underlayments are typically fastened with staples or roofing nails. Fasteners should be driven flush but not overdriven, which could tear the material. Rubberized asphalt is primarily self-adhering, but the top edge and side laps may require cap nails or staples for temporary fastening until the final roofing material is installed.
6. Working Up the Roof: Installation proceeds upwards towards the ridge, maintaining proper overlap at each course.
7. Valleys and Penetrations: Ice and water shield is commonly installed in valleys and around penetrations (chimneys, vents, skylights) before the main field underlayment. This creates a robust, self-sealing barrier in these critical areas.
8. Ridge: The underlayment from opposite sides of the roof should overlap at the ridge to ensure continuous protection.

Critical Installation Tip: Pay close attention to manufacturer instructions for specific overlap requirements, fastening patterns, and temperature limitations for installation, especially for adhesive underlayments. Improper installation is a leading cause of underlayment failure.

Underlayment's Role in the Complete Roofing System

Underlayment is not an isolated component; it's part of a layered system designed to protect your home. Understanding how it interacts with other parts of the roof is crucial.

• Deck: As discussed, the underlayment sits directly on the deck. The quality of the deck affects how well the underlayment can be installed and how effectively it protects the structure.
• Flashing: Flashing is installed at transitions and penetrations (valleys, chimneys, skylights, walls) to prevent water from entering. Ice and water shield often works in conjunction with flashing in these areas, providing a redundant waterproof layer beneath the metal or other flashing materials.
• Roofing Material (Shingles, Tile, Metal): The visible roofing material is the primary water shedder. The underlayment is the secondary barrier, catching any water that gets past the primary layer. The underlayment also protects the deck from the oils and other components in some roofing materials, preventing direct contact.
• Ventilation: Proper attic ventilation is vital for maintaining a healthy roof system. It helps regulate temperature and remove moisture vapor that rises from the living space into the attic. Inadequate ventilation can lead to moisture buildup on the underside of the roof deck, potentially affecting the underlayment and leading to rot. While felt is more breathable, even synthetic underlayment performs better with adequate ventilation. Ventilation also helps prevent ice dams by keeping the roof deck temperature more uniform.

System Harmony: All components of the roofing system – deck, underlayment, flashing, roofing material, and ventilation – must work together effectively for optimal performance and longevity. A failure in one component can compromise the entire system.

Longevity and Signs of Underlayment Issues

The lifespan of roof underlayment varies significantly by type and quality:

• #15 Felt: Typically lasts 15-20 years, sometimes less depending on exposure and installation.
• #30 Felt: Can last 20-30 years.
• Synthetic Underlayment: Many manufacturers warranty their synthetic products for 20-50 years, reflecting their expected lifespan, which often exceeds that of asphalt shingles.
• Rubberized Asphalt: Designed for maximum durability in critical areas, it can last 20-30 years or more, often outlasting the primary roofing material in those specific locations.

One challenge with underlayment is that it's hidden beneath the roofing material. You usually don't see it failing directly. However, signs of underlayment issues often manifest as leaks inside the home.

Signs that could indicate underlayment problems (among other roofing issues):

• Water stains on ceilings or walls, particularly after heavy rain or snowmelt.
• Dripping water inside the attic.
• Mold or mildew growth in the attic or on the underside of the roof deck.
• Sagging sections of the roof deck (indicating potential rot).
• Evidence of water penetration around chimneys, skylights, or in valleys.

If you notice any signs of a leak, it's critical to have your roof inspected promptly. While the issue might be damaged shingles or flashing, it could also point to a compromised underlayment layer beneath. Addressing leaks quickly can prevent minor issues from becoming major structural problems.

If you suspect a roof leak or have experienced storm damage, immediate professional assessment is necessary to identify the source and prevent further damage.
Book a roofing appointment

Planning Your Roofing Project

Whether you're dealing with an aging roof that's nearing the end of its lifespan or planning a replacement to upgrade your home, understanding the components like underlayment is a valuable first step. Knowing the options allows you to have informed discussions with roofing professionals about the best materials for your specific needs and the climate challenges of Portland.

For planned projects, such as budgeting for a future replacement or comparing different material costs (including the impact of underlayment choices), getting an initial estimate is a great way to start. This can help you understand the potential investment involved before committing to in-person consultations.

For non-urgent situations like planning a roof replacement or creating a budget for future projects, getting a quick, accurate estimate can help you explore your options.
Get your free instant roof estimate

When you are ready to proceed with a project or need a detailed assessment, booking an appointment connects you with qualified local roofers who can inspect your roof, evaluate the condition of the deck and existing underlayment, and recommend the best course of action, including the appropriate underlayment for your new roof.

The Unseen Shield Beneath Your Roof

While not visible from the street, the roof underlayment is a fundamental component of a robust roofing system. It acts as a critical secondary barrier against water, protects the roof deck, and contributes significantly to the overall longevity and performance of your roof. Whether you choose traditional felt, advanced synthetic, or premium rubberized asphalt for vulnerable areas, selecting the right type and ensuring proper installation are vital steps in safeguarding your home from the elements. Understanding this unseen shield gives you greater confidence in the protection your roof provides.